Old Fashioned Fudge Sauce

This old-fashioned hot fudge sauce is a tried-and-true classic: just the way your grandmother used to make it (or, more accurately, the way my grandmother used to make it, since this is based on her recipe).

This old-fashioned fudge sauce is divine drizzled on ice cream, but it’s also great blended into a classic chocolate malt, layered in an ice cream cake or simply stirred into a tall glass of milk.

Hot Fudge Sauce Recipe, the Old-fashioned way!

There are few things more satisfying than a big bowl of homemade vanilla ice cream, drizzled and drenched in rich chocolate fudge sauce.

You’re one cherry away from the ultimate fudge sundae. All that’s missing is a pile of rainbow sprinkles.

Old Fashioned Fudge Sauce from my Grandma's recipe!

There are generally two kinds of hot fudge sauce recipes: the melted-chocolate-and-cream ones (often touted as quick and easy – they are basically a really loose chocolate ganache), and then the old-fashioned kind, like this recipe, that’s no less quick and easy despite the “old fashioned” label that might imply otherwise. Think of the kind of fudge sauce you’d get at a retro soda fountain. That’s what we’re making here.

Based on my grandmother’s recipe, this hot fudge sauce is made with cocoa powder, sugar and invert syrup – it’s liquid fudge, essentially. The lack of dairy in this recipe makes it perfect for gifting or storing longer term (although I highly doubt it’ll last very long at all, it’s that good!)

I’d argue that have a good, classic fudge sauce recipe in your arsenal is essential.

But once you’ve got that mastered, well, feel free to go crazy!

For example, this basic recipe can easily be adapted into a chocolate peanut butter fudge sauce or a maple version that is incredible on chocolate chip pancakes (you’re going to have to buy the book to get that particular recipe!)

Old Fashioned Fudge Sauce Recipe with Cocoa Powder

Looking for some more flavor variations?

Add a splash of creme de menthe or peppermint extract for a chocolate mint fudge sauce that would be perfect for the holidays.

Add a pinch of cayenne pepper and cinnamon for a spicy Aztec chocolate fudge sauce.

Whisk in a tablespoon or two of bourbon just as the sauce comes off the heat for a boozy chocolate delight.

This old-fashioned fudge sauce is a bit thinner than the thick, scoopable stuff you might find in a jar. The invert syrup here keeps it liquid even at cold/frozen temperatures, which means it’s going to stay gooey and oozy even when layered and frozen in an ice cream cake.

It also means you don’t have to warm it up if you don’t want to, it’s perfectly drizzable in its refrigerated form (but, that said, warm fudge sauce on cold ice cream is a thing of beauty).